Featured Image

Inflation: A Look Back for a Look Up?

While it may be politically expedient to blame economic ills, including inflation, on the party in control of Congress or the occupant of the White House, actual causes of economic phenomena are a web of interwoven issues.
Feb 04, 2022

Inflation has come to dominate conversations taking place from the kitchen table to trading floors and beyond. Policymakers initially labeled the rising prices as transitory, meaning it was a temporary condition brought about by a mismatch between the amount of goods in demand and what could be supplied. A look back at some recent trends in fiscal policy, shifting consumer habits, and changes to Federal Reserve policy can reveal the extent to which the increased prices we are facing are rooted in supply constraints or due to excess economic activity. However, to fully understand the impacts, differences between the 2020 COVID recession and all previous ones should be appreciated.

Fighting the 2020 Recession

While the circumstances around each one are different, every recession is brought about by a general decrease in demand for goods and services. This reduction in demand causes businesses to lay off workers, close their doors, or reduce output by other means, creating unemployment and further reductions in demand. The economic contraction of 2020 was quite different. The service industry was disproportionally affected by a near cessation of activity, while workers who could work remotely and those deemed “essential” generally remained employed.

Amid this backdrop, fiscal stimulus at the federal level was passed to assist both businesses and workers who felt the disruption of the shutdown. Government spending itself does not cause inflation, but the cash transfers enacted under both the Trump and Biden administrations were designed to bolster consumption and had the potential to be inflationary. Nearly $700 billion was spent to augment state unemployment programs. While increasing unemployment benefits can contribute to inflationary pressures, observed inflation only began to increase toward the end of this program and only peaked after the additional benefits expired in September 2021. In addition to the increased unemployment benefits, three rounds of direct cash payments costing over $850 billion were sent directly to most Americans. Since these transfers were not means-tested like unemployment, they were far more likely to bring about excess consumption and inflationary pressures. The total impact on inflation was muted because of the high propensity to save these cash injections as well as a portion of wages that normally would have been spent. Between January 2020 and January 2021, the total deposits in commercial banks increased by nearly $3 trillion.

Consumer Spending

As the shutdown continued and service sectors remained closed or operating at severely diminished capacity, consumers began to shift their spending habits toward goods. Following the 2008 financial crisis, it took five years for consumer spending to surpass pre-recession levels. By contrast, consumer spending surpassed pre-pandemic levels by June 2020 and peaked in April 2021, 39% above February 2020. The shift in consumer demands required an economy-wide shift in capacity toward manufactured goods, which would require significant investment and time. The recovery from the previous recession was characterized by an extended period of persistently low inflation. One of the main reasons for this was the Federal Reserve’s policy of forward guidance and an ardent defense of the 2% inflation target. Because changes in expected inflation will lead to a proportional change in actual inflation, hard targeting 2% anchored expectations no higher than that. When this targeting policy was abandoned in August 2020 in favor of a new regime of “Average Inflation Targeting,” the Fed nearly guaranteed the recovery from the COVID shutdowns would be accompanied by a high inflationary environment, as the 2% upper limit on expectations was removed.

Not So Simple

While it may be politically expedient to blame economic ills, including inflation, on the party in control of Congress or the occupant of the White House, actual causes of economic phenomena are a web of interwoven issues. Allowing natural inflation to grow unchecked risks overheating the economy and causing financial troubles for families and businesses, yet tightening monetary accommodation too early risks returning to the shallow growth environment following the financial crisis, if not plunging back into recession. Understanding the underlying factors and their relative impact will help guide future policy to alleviate the burden of inflation without putting undue restriction on economic growth.

PicturePicture
Author
Christopher Chidzik
Principal Economist
Recent intelligence News
At the AMT Winter Economic Forum, economists predicted the upcoming year will feature several opportunities for manufacturers as the economy comes in for a soft landing, including 8% growth in manufacturing technology orders. Is your company ready?
Geopolitical tensions. Recessionary fears. A presidential election. With this much global volatility, it’s more important than ever to get good, reliable market data and insights. Join us for the latest industry forecasts at the 2024 Winter Economic Forum.
Recent trends captured by the U.S. Manufacturing Technology Orders Report published by AMT – The Association For Manufacturing Technology indicate that orders for manufacturing technology indeed responded “very, very quickly” to the rate-hiking cycle.
When facing the prospect of industry-specific slowdowns or a rolling recession, it is important to use the data most applicable to your industry to track your performance and anticipate changing customer demand.
Comparing USMTO data to industrial production data in past recessions provides interesting insight into what to expect in future downturns.
Similar News
undefined
International
By Carlos Mortera | Mar 26, 2024

Brazil revs up with massive automotive investments while Mexico sees lots of new developments across all sectors. The two great engines of Latin America are making the soft landing happen. For more industry intel and other tidbits, read on.

5 min
undefined
Technology
By Benjamin Moses | Mar 22, 2024

Episode 115: The gang talks about dogs and other furry friends. Elissa reports that Japan’s about to land on the moon. Ben discusses stainless steel corrosion. Stephen closes with an “ICYMI” on everything we may have missed with the Boeing situation.

29 min
undefined
Advocacy
By Harry Moser | Mar 22, 2024

As global dynamics evolve, a transition to productivism prioritizes local investment. U.S. defense strategy and strategic policy development foster resilient supply chains as reshoring trends see economic benefits. Learn how this affects your business.

5 min